Luxury home kitchen and living space
    Capital Gains Tax Deferral

    The Deferred Sales Trust™

    A Capital Gains Tax Deferral Solution

    Those of us who own highly appreciated assets such as homes, commercial real estate and businesses are often reluctant to sell those assets due to the capital gains tax and depreciation recapture costs associated with the sale. With the Deferred Sales Trust, Estate Planning Team presents a solution that allows a seller to defer their capital gains tax and potentially reduce the overall tax burden.

    Additionally, many people do not realize the high costs associated with estate tax and with having to wait for "step-up" values. The Deferred Sales Trust offers a smart, functional, and legal way to address these issues.

    The DST utilizes IRS tax code that allows the seller of the property to defer capital gains taxes due at the time of sale over a period of time that is selected by the Seller/Taxpayer in advance. It may be a fit for owners of businesses or real estate that has significantly appreciated, or for those who are having trouble finding suitable, qualified property exchanges.

    Deferring taxes legally is not new. Some commonly used tax deferral methods include 1031 exchanges, charitable trusts, and traditional seller carry-back installment sale contracts. Trust law predates the formation of the U.S. law and tax law. Various types of trusts are used by millions of Americans to protect and preserve their wealth for themselves and their heirs.

    The DST can be used with any kind of entity, e.g., LLCs, S or C-election corporations, as well as individuals who own real estate, rental properties, vacation homes, farm or commercial properties, hotels, vacant land, industrial complexes, retail developments, and raw land, to name a few.

    What Are Long-Term Capital Gains Taxes?

    Long-term capital gains tax is simply defined as the tax we pay on the profit we make when we sell a capital asset we've held for a year or more. Capital gains tax is calculated by subtracting what you paid for the asset from the net selling price. The current long term capital gains tax rate for a capital asset owned for one year or longer is typically 15% - 20% for Federal taxes.

    Back in 2013, there was an additional Federal tax added on income, known as the Investment Income Tax (Funding Medicare). This Investment Income Tax has an applicable rate of 3.8% on some (but not all) income from interest, dividends, rents (less expenses) and capital gains (less capital losses). Most states charge 5% to 10% on top of that (CA is as high as 13.3%), making the total tax run as high as 37.1%. If there was depreciation taken on the asset, the cost basis is lowered by that amount, thus increasing the taxable gain!

    Even with your primary residence, factoring in your tax exemption of $250,000 each for husband and wife, you may still have a hefty tax surprise with your capital gains taxes when you sell your property.

    That isn't the end of the story for the total tax effect. Capital gain is added to the taxpayer's adjusted gross income (AGI). This may raise the "floor" above which one can take a number of itemized deductions and affect, consequently, the Alternative Minimum Tax.

    This could result in a large decrease or total loss of those deductions, which makes the effective, but hidden, capital gains rate much larger than the stated federal and state rates. And, of course, tax payment obligations would begin immediately.

    To make matters worse, the capital gains and depreciation recapture taxes must be paid in the following tax year after the sale of the asset.

    How Does the DST Work?

    The process starts with initial due diligence and prospective marketing and market research. If the transaction is viable, the trust and property owner will negotiate to reach terms for the asset(s). If the transaction is feasible, the property owner, ("seller/taxpayer"), sells ownership of the property/capital asset to a dedicated trust (the "trust").

    Next, the approved and DST trained trustee of the trust pays the seller/taxpayer for the property/capital asset. The payment isn't in cash, but with a payment contract called an "installment sales contract" which is a private agreement between the trust and the seller/taxpayer. The terms of payment are established in advance and pursuant to the sale contract negotiated by and between the seller/taxpayer and the trustee.

    The payments may begin immediately, or they may be deferred for some period of months or years. The trust then sells the property. There are generally minimal capital gains taxes due from the trust on the sale, since the trust often purchases the property for a price and value similar to what it may get sold to a third-party Buyer.

    The seller/taxpayer is not taxed on the sale since he or she has not yet received any cash for the sale. Payments may begin immediately but often times a seller/taxpayers will choose deferral because they have other income and don't need the payments right away.

    Deferral is strictly an option. It is important to understand that payment of the capital gains tax to the IRS is done with an "easy installment plan" as the seller/taxpayer receives the payments. Part of the payment received is tax-free return of basis, part is return of gain which is taxed at capital gains rates, and part is interest.

    On top of that, the tax payments will be made with depreciated dollars. The tax dollars will likely be worth less than they are today due to inflation. If invested properly, the money in the trust could potentially grow at a greater rate than that of inflation and even the distribution rate, and ensures the necessary liquidity to pay back the note due to the seller/taxpayer. The interest rate in the note to you is dictated by the IRS to be a fair and arms length or a competitive rate, i.e., 6% to 8%.

    While we have primarily focused on capital gains tax, the amount of gain due to straight line depreciation is also deferred with a DST. However, if you have taken accelerated depreciation in excess over straight line, this amount is not deferrable.

    There is proper diversification by the DST Trustee when investing the DST's funds. The DST Trustee may invest in REIT's, bonds, annuities, securities or other "prudent investments" that are suitable to help assure the trustee's performance in repaying the seller/taxpayer pursuant to the held installment sales note. The DST Trustee's reinvestment of the proceeds may result in more or less risk depending on the nature of where the proceeds are reinvested. An inherent goal of the trust's investment objective is simply to produce the cash flow necessary for the scheduled installment sales note payments to the seller/taxpayer.

    Significant Benefits to a Seller Using the Deferred Sales Trust When Selling Their Asset:

    1. Tax Deferral

    When appreciated property/capital assets are sold, capital gains tax on said sale is generally deferred until the seller/taxpayer actually receives the payments.

    2. Estate Tax Benefits

    May accomplish an "estate tax freeze" for estate tax purposes.

    3. Maintains Family Wealth

    When properly structured, the principal inside the subject installment sales note can be preserved with "interest only" or partial principal payments, creating the potential to pass on a large portion of the note principal to your legal heirs with proper estate planning.

    4. Estate Liquidity

    Converts an illiquid asset into monthly payments.

    5. Retirement Income

    Provides a stream of income that can be used as retirement income.

    6. Probate Avoidance

    With proper estate planning.

    7. Eliminates Risks Associated with Ownership

    By utilizing the DST, you have taken an asset that is otherwise "exposed" to liability and potentially converted it to a "no-liability" asset.

    Nothing is required to be given away to charity as happens with the competing strategy known as a Charitable Remainder Trust. The DST allows all due principal and accrued interest to be paid to the seller/taxpayer via a custom prepared installment sales agreement, whereas the Charitable Remainder Trust often pays income (interest) only.

    The DST has the potential and likelihood to yield more bottom line dollars to the property/capital asset seller/taxpayer than a Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT).

    The DST has the ability to generate substantially more wealth over the long run than a direct and taxed sale. It may be superior to the Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT), installment sale or like-kind property exchange in many respects. Consult your tax advisor to ascertain the potential benefits of this option.

    Educational Disclaimer

    This article is for educational purposes and is solely intended to provide an overview on how the Deferred Sales Trust works and can be implemented. Estate Planning Team does not provide legal, tax professional services, or advice. Each transaction and individual circumstances vary widely and participants are strongly urged to seek independent legal, tax and professional advice.

    IRS Circular 230 Disclosure

    IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Clear answers to help you understand your capital gains tax options.

    How do you determine my payments from the Trust?

    The payments are based on what you, the seller/taxpayer, arrange and pre-negotiate with the DST trained and approved trustee. Depending on your income goals and other objectives, the amount and length of term of the installment sales note are your choice and subject to your approval.

    What happens if I die?

    With proper estate planning (i.e., by creating a Living Trust) scheduled installment note payments otherwise due to you can continue to pay to your legal heirs pursuant to the note term that you have chosen.

    Is the amount and frequency of my payments flexible?

    Yes. The DST Trustee in his or her absolute discretion may allow you to renegotiate the terms of your installment note.

    Can I cancel the promissory note at any time and be paid off?

    If the DST Trustee deems appropriate, he/she may elect to terminate the installment sales contract. However, you would immediately owe all the taxes, including all unpaid capital gains due from the original sale of the property/capital asset.

    What happens if capital gains tax rates are changed after I set up the DST?

    Politicians, from time to time, discuss changing capital gains rates. If that happens you would pay the new rate on the capital gains portion of your installment note payments as they are received. However, there is usually adequate notice to make a sound financial decision prior to any such change in taxation or tax rates.

    Can I use my installment sales note to get back into real estate?

    Yes, please contact the Estate Planning Team or a duly qualified DST attorney to discuss this option.

    When the trust sells the property may I keep some of the cash from the sale?

    Yes, in that case you would pay taxes only on the capital gain portion of the money which you kept for yourself outside the trust.

    How can I have my tax advisor or attorney analyze the DST strategy?

    For detailed technical information, have your CPA contact EPT to discuss your scenario with an attorney with DST experience. The names Deferred Sales Trust and DST were created to describe a technique and are not specifically found in the code. All of the legal and tax authority used in the DST are in the tax code, treasury regulations, cases, or rulings based upon the foundations found within the tax law.

    I’m interested in finding out if this works for me. What should I do next?

    It’s very easy. Your next step is to complete an illustration request on my website. Once you have received the illustration summary, you can then review this information with a trust case manager and share this information with your CPA or tax attorney for further review.

    Tax Solution Consultation

    Request a consultation to explore whether the Deferred Sales Trust™ may be a fit for your situation. We'll be in touch within 24 hours.

    This form is for consultation requests only and does not constitute legal or tax advice.